So what were my results? We'll count down in reverse chronological order. For those of you tired of looking at commons from the last 20 years, scroll down a bit.
14. 2008 Jamie Moyer

13. 2005 Cleveland Indians Team Card

12. 2005 Oscar Viarreal

11. 1999 Andy Pettite

10. 1993 Cris Colon

9. 1987 Ozzie Smith

8. 1987 Rod Scurry

7. 1987 Joe Hesketh

6. 1985 Dave Von Ohlen

5. 1985 Gary Redus

4. 1975 Dave LaRoche

3. 1971 Steve Hargan

2. 1960 Bob Oldis

1. 1956 "Bud" Podbielan

Not the most amazing haul and certainly no huge scores, but I was pretty excited to see a couple of cards from the 70s show up, so then seeing a 1960 and a 1956 were just awesome. 1956 Topps is easily on of my favorite baseball card sets ever, so getting a card, even of a very marginal player, is pretty sweet.
Go Halos!